elect.horse

(elect.horse)

244 points | by solarist 4 hours ago

12 comments

  • tejstead 2 hours ago
    I think this is basically a copy of Gerrymandle?
    • Symbiote 2 hours ago
      It looks like it: https://gerrymandle.com/
      • echelon 37 minutes ago
        The horse version feels more fun and cozy.
      • elxr 1 hour ago
        This one doesn't load for me
    • zimpenfish 19 minutes ago
      You could add "pretty shameless" before "copy" there. Sheesh.

      What next? words.horse which is just Wordle?

    • curtisf 1 hour ago
      • tialaramex 13 minutes ago
        Yeah, when I saw elect.horse I didn't think "Ooh, a new game I've never imagined before". This is a problem, but you can show the problem as part of a fun game. Like Monopoly the point isn't that this is an awesome game, the point is that it's a real problem, but if you have fun that's great too. If you get somewhat good at the game, you can understand the problem better.
      • MattRix 16 minutes ago
        Yes but surely you can see that this is copying much more than just the general idea of a game about gerrymandering.
        • tialaramex 9 minutes ago
          I don't see it, but maybe you have examples where there are specific choices which were copied?
    • tarpitt 15 minutes ago
      Gerrymandle doesn't have horses
    • duskdozer 1 hour ago
      Seems like it, though this has a second puzzle with three candidates instead of two
      • manarth 1 hour ago
        Gerrymandle interchanges the number of candidates: sometimes two, sometimes three, sometimes more
        • duskdozer 46 minutes ago
          Ah. First time I've seen either.
    • paulnpace 18 minutes ago
      With you always working make sure blue wins.
    • bibinou 48 minutes ago
      [dead]
  • chinathrow 2 hours ago
  • ivanjermakov 17 minutes ago
    Competitve side is much weaker than in enclose.horse, this game only measures hints used.
  • andrewrn 2 minutes ago
    Fun game!
  • Agentlien 2 hours ago
    It's fun but I can barely see the difference between the horse and donkey colors which makes it really hard.
    • antonyh 27 minutes ago
      I don't have colour blindness, I have a colour calibrated display, and I find it hard to differentiate between them.

      Also, Firefox blocking Canvas elements does something really funky to the hex tiles making it harder. Allowing access does make the tile background change to pink/yellow-green instead of them all being lilac/lavender/purple animations.

      The colours make it too difficult for me on a good display, and the dancing 'thing' (wheat?) doesn't help.

      • llm_nerd 10 minutes ago
        It seems that you're indirectly citing my comment, so I have to reply.

        You really have trouble differentiating between 5fd3ff and b58cff? These are dramatically different hues (65 degrees on the colour wheel).

        I mean, maybe the site is A:B testing different hue combinations, or there is a technical fault happening for some users, but if you really have trouble differentiating those two hues, one of your two declarations at the beginning of your comment must be false.

    • pge 1 hour ago
      I am color blind (red-green) and have the same issue. Not a color-blind friendly color scheme...
    • llm_nerd 1 hour ago
      FWIW, they are pretty distinct hues, and are easily discernible. I only mention this because a lot of people go through life not realizing they suffer some form of colour blindness, so it's worth knowing. Another possibility is that you're looking at it on a very poor display.

      EDIT: I've now been "downvoted" multiple times for this harmless observation, and now have a clown declaring me a "bad llm". Is this what HN is reduced to?

      • Agentlien 33 minutes ago
        I know I've got deuteranopia. That doesn't help. I still can barely see the difference. What would have helped is picking two colors which weren't so close for people with such a common issue.

        What frustrates me is that this has happened even with color coding in video games where I myself was part of the UI team and flagged the issue a year before release. (Need For Speed, 2015)

        • llm_nerd 23 minutes ago
          > I know I've got deuteranopia. That doesn't help.

          Seems like something you should probably declare upfront if you're complaining about the colour choices, right? As is your comment looks weird to the vast majority of people -- and yes, the vast majority of people are not colour blind -- who have no issues with the colours.

          Should every colour-based game, chart, display, and so on have colour blind modes or safer colour selections? Sure.

      • ThrowawayTestr 38 minutes ago
        You are correct. If you can't tell the difference between purple and cyan you probably have color blindness.
      • Muromec 55 minutes ago
        bad llm
        • llm_nerd 50 minutes ago
          Uh, what? What is the point of your worthless comment?
    • Tepix 1 hour ago
      [flagged]
      • mixtureoftakes 1 hour ago
        got me wondering how many complaints you see online are one shottable by any decent model with 30 seconds of "i have this issue: . provide easiest working solution" prompting
        • throw310822 54 minutes ago
          Yesterday I was watching a tv program online on the legitimate website of the broadcaster, but I was really annoyed at the fact that the video stopped whenever I left the tab. So I opened Chrome's devtools, went to the AI tab ad exposed my complaint. In a few seconds it had analysed all the minified sources of the website, found which tracker was responsible of this, and written a script to disable it. Lovely.
    • Razengan 2 hours ago
      That in itself might be a social commentary.. :)
      • Jtarii 1 hour ago
        Sure, if you have an IQ of 80.
        • fancyfredbot 1 hour ago
          For people with IQ over 80, highlighting that people in different tribes are actually alike doesn't count as social commentary?
          • Jtarii 1 hour ago
            The only people who think republicans and democrats are exactly the same have an IQ of 80.

            The "both sides" meme was funny when jon stewart was doing it in 2008. It has run its course.

            • fancyfredbot 1 hour ago
              I took it as a comment about voters than parties.

              It didn't even occur to me that it was saying republicans and democrats are the same. That's just ridiculous ;-)

              Edit: To clarify there's good evidence that people overestimate the degree to which people on the other side of the political divide hold extreme views by about a factor of two. We genuinely are less different than we think. It's not necessary for people to be the same for this to be true.

              • paulryanrogers 46 minutes ago
                > To clarify there's good evidence that people overestimate the degree to which people on the other side of the political divide hold extreme views by about a factor of two.

                Where can I read more about that evidence?

                Because ~70 million of my countrymen have voted for a convicted rapist.

            • xienze 1 hour ago
              Surely you agree that "both sides" think the other side is full of evil politicians that want to destroy the country AND their voters are complete morons?

              And surely you can agree that each side has key issues they feel very strongly about (abortion on the left, guns on the right) and again, think the other side's view on said issues are utterly disgusting, right?

              And SURELY you can agree that gerrymandering has occurred at various times in the past, from both sides, can't you? For example, take a look at the map of Illinois congressional districts[0]. Perfectly sensible districts here, yessir!

              The low IQ take is pretending there aren't places where both sides do in fact behave the same way.

              0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illinois%27s_congressional_dis...

              • tialaramex 30 minutes ago
                What you'd expect to see in a healthy democracy is people who want to fix the bug, and for a while maybe those who most benefit from the bug fight to keep it but eventually there's a broad public sentiment in favour of fixing the bug and so it simply becomes uncontroversial to fix it. Say fifty years. Give it an extra generation if e.g. civil war breaks out interrupting such considerations.

                But Gerry died in the nineteenth century. This practice is almost as old as the United States of America itself. I would say it's as bad as if the US still had slavery, or still had capital punishment, but oh yeah it still has both of those too. Do better.

  • jawns 33 minutes ago
    I am a big fan of both enclose.horse and gerrymandle.com. I play both daily.

    But this rip-off of gerrymandle.com makes me feel less inclined to continue playing enclose.horse.

    And yes, it is a rip-off, not merely a riff on the general puzzle game of this type.

    It's akin to joke stealing among comedians. It makes you lose respect for the joke stealer, even if their original stuff is good.

    • joshuaS98 31 minutes ago
      It's the same developer...
      • alstonite 24 minutes ago
        What’s your source on that? The owners of Enclose.horse don’t list gerrymandle as one of their games: https://clevergoat.com/all-games
        • efilife 20 minutes ago
          He means that enclose.horse and elect.horse are from the same developers.

          (which isn't true btw, enclose.horse was sold by the original developer)

          • joshuaS98 18 minutes ago
            I mean to say that it's owned by the same people
    • Labo333 24 minutes ago
      To the other commenters: @jawns means a rip-off of gerrymandle.com
    • jwilcoxson 25 minutes ago
      It literally says “also by us: enclose.horse”
      • MattRix 15 minutes ago
        lol we know it's by the same people as enclose horse, the issue is that it rips off gerrymandle
    • yohannparis 31 minutes ago
      It's from the same people!
  • anonymous908213 1 hour ago
    enclose.horse was sold off not too long after it was published. The new owners now seem to be doing a shameless cash grab, ripping off gerrymandle.com 1:1, down to some particularly weird UI choices, and the text copy is transparently LLM-generated. It would be one thing if they added some kind of improvement or unique take, but reskinning (with assets you bought) and throwing ads on it is, frankly, just lame.
    • asmosoinio 1 hour ago
      To whom was it sold? Any reference for that?

      I still thought it was some single persons product.

      Update; ah ok sold to two people, not some huge company - https://enclose.horse/about-us:

      ---- Our Story

      Enclose.horse was originally created by Shivers as an interesting optimization problem, the kind of thing you'd find in a Leetcode challenge or an Advent of Code puzzle. But after prototyping it, it turned out to be genuinely fun to play, and it grew into a fully-fledged game.

      Today, enclose.horse is developed and maintained by Ryan and Praveen. We're constantly adding new features, puzzle mechanics, and quality-of-life improvements based on community feedback. If you have ideas, we'd love to hear them!

    • alembic_fumes 1 hour ago
      > ripping off gerrymandle.com

      I'm used to game developers sometimes displaying their political preferences through their art, but I have to say that Gerrymandle's "Win the election for orange." is still quite on the nose!

      • toyg 1 hour ago
        For the record, it's just the current puzzle - the colors vary pretty wildly, see for example the previous one: https://gerrymandle.com/game/2026-10-29
        • anonymous908213 1 hour ago
          There's also a colorblind mode where you can always win the election for blue, if that's more to your political preference! I like that mode just for keeping the colors consistent.
      • manarth 1 hour ago
        "Win the election for <color>" is Gerrymandle's standard text, and the color changes for each daily puzzle.
  • swiftcoder 1 hour ago
    That's a really concrete demonstration of gerrymandering. Assign it in schools!
  • petterroea 24 minutes ago
    Big fan of enclose.horse. Happy there is a sequel
  • ghrl 2 hours ago
    Meant to post this, too.

    Another great game from the enclose.horse game, both are very fun and really challenging to play depending on the level.

  • joshuaS98 40 minutes ago
    day 8 expert took me about 40 seconds
  • teekert 1 hour ago